How To Appeal An Unemployment Overpayment
If your state unemployment agency sends you an overpayment notice, it means it believes you received unemployment benefits for which you were not entitled. The alleged overpayments may have occurred if the unemployment agency believes you didnt report part-time earnings while collecting benefits, or went back to work and continued to collect benefits after starting a full-time job. Although each states laws and procedures for appealing overpayment differ, most unemployment departments require you to prove you were entitled to the benefits or that you didnt receive the overpayment due to fraudulent activity on your part.
Read Also: How Do I Track My Unemployment Card
How To Win Your Unemployment Appeal Hearing If You Voluntarily Quit
How to win your unemployment appeal hearing if you voluntarily quit
Generally speaking, voluntary quit cases are the hardest to win. This is because in these cases the burden falls on you, the claimant, to prove that you quit for a necessitous or compelling reason. While it certainly may be difficult, it is not impossible to win as there are many valid reasons a person may quit their job.
With the help of a skilled and experienced employment law attorney, you can win your unemployment appeal hearing if you:
What is considered a necessitous or compelling reason for quitting your job?
The law recognizes there are circumstances in which one may feel they had no other option but to quit their job. For example, if you are suffering from a medical condition which may be made worse by working and there is no way for your employer to accommodate you. Another example may be that either your office relocated or maybe your spouse had to relocate for their job.
Some other examples of what could be considered a necessitous and compelling reason are:
What Happens If I Win My Appeal
If you win the appeal, you will be entitled to collect benefits in the future. You will also be entitled to collect any benefits that you certified for but were not paid following the initial determination of ineligibility. Therefore, it is critical that you continue to certify for benefits while you are awaiting your appeal. Your employer may still appeal the new decision to a higher level. Watch for any correspondence from the employer or the unemployment agency. You may be required to submit a written letter explaining why the appeal decision was correct.
Read Also: Apply For Unemployment In Missouri
What Will Happen At The Hearing
The judge typically will ask you questions, which you should answer. If there is anything that you believe is important that the judge leaves out, you should respectfully ask for the opportunity to testify about it. After you testify, you will have the opportunity to ask questions of the other side and ultimately to make a closing statement of why you should receive unemployment benefits.
How To Prepare For Your Hearing
To prepare for the hearing, think about how you can prove that you had to quit. If you quit for medical reasons, ask your doctor to document your condition and why you could no longer do your job. If you quit to relocate with your spouse, get a copy of your spouse’s offer letter or official paperwork from the military , as well as any documents showing when you moved.
If you were constructively discharged, you will need evidence that your working conditions were intolerable and you had no choice but to quit. If you were sent harassing email messages, get copies of those. If you filed a complaint of unsafe working conditions or discrimination, get a copy of the paperwork. If coworkers are willing to provide statements about your situation, those may be helpful as well. Anything you can present to show that your situation was untenable and you gave the company an opportunity to correct it will help your case.
Also Check: Maximum Unemployment Benefits Mn
Next Steps For Appeal Your Unemployment Benefits Decision
Once your request is received
When we receive your request, we will send you 2 letters, either electronically or by U.S. Mail, depending on the method you selected when you filed your claim for benefits. The first letter is sent immediately to confirm we received your appeal request. The second letter is sent when we schedule the hearing. The Notice of Hearing will:
How to prepare for your hearing
The Department of Unemployment Assistance offers the following tips to prepare for a hearing:
If you disagree with the review examiners decision
You may appeal to the Board of Review.
How To Beat Unemployment Claims
When employers ask how to beat unemployment claims its usually in the context of an upcoming claim hearing, or trying to decide whether or not to contest a claim.
Ideally, most of the steps involved in successfully contesting an unemployment claim begin before that stage. The best way to avoid losing an unemployment claim dispute is to prevent it from happening in the first place.
Still, there are strategies for beating an unemployment claim that will help better your odds at any stage of the process.
Recommended Reading: Applying For Unemployment Tennessee
Determining Your Eligibility For Unemployment Benefits
Good cause is determined by your state unemployment office, and it varies from state to state. For instance, some states consider quitting due to a spouse’s new out-of-state job as good cause, while others only consider that good cause if the move is due to a spouse’s military transfer.
When you file for unemployment, you will be able to make a case for why you are eligible for unemployment benefits if the employer contests your claim. If your claim is denied, you should be entitled to a hearing where you can plead your case.
If you are planning to quit your job and you are not sure whether you’re eligible, check with your state unemployment office to determine your eligibility for unemployment compensation prior to announcing your resignation. They can help you to assess your case for claiming good cause.
I Quit Because My Boss Told Me Id Be Fired If I Didnt Quit He Said It Would Look Better On My Record If I Resigned Can I Get Unemployment Benefits
This is called a Quit Or Be Fired situation. If you prove thats what happened, then the unemployment agency will NOT regard this as a voluntary quit. Because it wasnt voluntary. You were fired. You had no choice about the job ending. Thats not a quit.
Because it was really a firing, the unemployment agency will treat it like any other discharge case. The agency will ask whether there was Simple Misconduct, or Gross Misconduct, that caused the Quit Or Be Fired order. If there was no Misconduct, there will be no penalty.
In this situation, it is really important for you to tell Unemployment that you didnt actually quit. Explain that you were given a Quit Or Be Fired ultimatum.
It will be up to you to prove that you were put in this Quit Or Be Fired situation. You will have to show that you did not choose to quit. Once you prove that, the agency will not impose a Voluntary Quit penalty.
Read Also: File For Unemployment Pennsylvania
Request A Free Consultation
I Quit Because The Company Wasnt Maintaining A Safe Workplace Or Didnt Give Me The Safety Equipment Needed For The Job Can I Get Unemployment Benefits
Yes, if you prove that the company was aware of the unsafe conditions and did not take reasonable steps to fix them.
Example benefits awarded: you were employed as a tree trimmer, working high up in trees. The safety harness you were supposed to use was old, and had cracks and tears. The company refused to replace it with a good one, and told you to do your work anyway. This is Good Cause, and it involves Fault on the Part of the Employer. You will not be disqualified from benefits.
Example benefits denied: You were employed as a tree trimmer, working high up in trees. The company gives you all the harnesses and safety gear that OSHA requires. But you want even more safety protections. Because the company has followed OSHA regulations and given you all required safety gear, that company will not be at fault. If you quit, you will probably be disqualified from all benefits.
Recommended Reading: Njuifile Login
Do You Have Good Cause To Quit
If you left your job to pursue other opportunities, change careers, start your own business, or go back to school, you didn’t have “good cause” to quit. These are all very good reasons to leave a job, but they don’t entitle you to collect unemployment benefits. Good cause means you really didn’t have another choice.
In some states, benefits will be paid only to those who had job-related reasons for quitting, such as unsafe working conditions. In other states, an employee who has compelling personal reasons to quit will also be eligible for benefits.
Here are some situations in which you might have good cause to quitand be eligible for unemployment benefits:
Your state may define good cause more generously. For example, some states provide benefits to an employee who quit to move with a spouse who has accepted a job in another state or has been reposted by the military.
To find out what your state considers good cause for quitting, contact your state’s unemployment insurance agency.
Reasons Why An Unemployment Claim Might Be Denied
If your claim was denied, it might be because your state determined that you failed to meet one or more eligibility criteria. Here are some of the most common reasons you might be found ineligible for unemployment:
- You are not currently able to work. In order to collect unemployment, you must be able to work. If you cant work for due to illness or injury, you might be eligible for other benefits, such as temporary disability insurance.
- Youre not available to work. The state most likely will not approve a claim for unemployment benefits if it concludes that you intend to take time off from work, even if it is for a noble purpose like spending more time with family.
- You were fired for cause. Unemployment benefits are available to people who are out of work through no fault of their own. This might include layoffs, reductions in force, business closures, and other events that do not involve any wrongdoing on your part. If you were fired for serious misconduct, you probably wont be eligible for unemployment.
- You quit or resigned voluntarily. In most cases, you wont be eligible for unemployment if you left your last job of your own free will. However, some exceptions applyfor example, if you quit due to workplace harassment.
- You dont meet the earnings requirements. Each state requires you to meet minimum earnings or hours worked requirements to qualify for unemployment.
You May Like: How Do I Sign Up For Unemployment In Washington State
Read Also: Va Individual Unemployability Benefits
Reasons Why You Were Disqualified:
1. You did not earn enough money
The Texas Workforce Commission will take a look at a workers base earnings reported from your past employer. If they determine you did not earn enough to warrant any benefits, you must show proof such as paystubs or a W-2 when appealing.
2. You quit your job for non-COVID-19 reasons
Filers wont be penalized if they had to quit due to COVID-19 concerns or exposure. If you quit for other reasons such as an opportunity, you will not earn benefits.
TWC stated that if you quit your job due to unsafe working conditions, or an illness other than COVID-19, you are eligible for benefits.
3. You left important information out of your application
Maybe you left out certain job history in your application, or miscounted the earnings you reported. TWC will verify the information you provided on your file with the employer in question. You may have to go through the appeals process to provide additional verification in order to back up your information, according to The Motley Fool.
4. You are earning paid leave from your company
Some employers provided paid leave for their employees who left their jobs due to COVID-19. This can conflict with unemployment benefits and will result in a denied application, The Motley Fool reported.
Once the employer-paid leave runs out, you can resubmit your application.
5. You were separated from your job due to misconduct or other non-COVID-19 reasons
You May Like: How Do I Change My Address For Unemployment Online
Ten Reasons To Choose Our Law Firm
1. Focused Employment Law Practice
MKO is a boutique law firm which means that we concentrate on this niche area and offer highly focused employment law services to clients who are looking for the personal touch. Boutique law firms are not a one-stop legal shop, and thats a good thing. While a long roster of diverse legal services may look impressive on paper, its fairly pointless in practice. You need one good attorney who knows the ins and outs of the area of law thats relevant to your case. Look for a law firm that only practices in the area of law that you need. If thats all they do, chances are, they do it very well.
2. Technology Driven & Experts in the Cloud
We provide immediate legal consultations, operate a paperless law firm, use advanced cloud storage, digital signatures, electronic forms, and can review your documents using screen share technology instantaneously. MKO is technologically savvy, nimble, flexible, and efficient.
We are not confined to our office, chained to a desktop computer, or burdened with IT maintenance. Thanks to the smart use of technology we can focus on providing our clients with the best representation possible. By streamlining our practice we can focus on what our clients hire us to do advocate on their behalf and work diligently toward a desired result.
3. Legal Advice Instantly From The Comfort of Home
4. Discreet When Necessary
Confidentiality is key, for everyone.
5. Experience, Professional, & Integrity
Read Also: Applying For Unemployment In Louisiana
If Your Unemployment Claim Is Denied Heres How To Appeal The Decision
By Lisa Guerin, J.D.
Once you file a claim for unemployment benefits, the state unemployment agency will review the information you provide, talk to your past employer, and possibly interview you . After its review is complete, the agency will either grant or deny your claim for unemployment benefits. If your claim is granted, you will soon start filing weekly claims for unemployment benefitsand receiving your unemployment checks. But what if your claim is denied?
If your claim for unemployment compensation is denied, you can file an appeal arguing that the agencys finding was incorrect. This article explains some common reasons why claims for unemployment benefits are denied and provides some basic information on the appeals process.
If You Had Good Cause To Quit Your Job You May Still Be Eligible For Unemployment Benefits
Updated by Aaron Hotfelder, J.D., University of Missouri School of Law
Unemployment benefits are provided only to those who are out of work through no fault of their own. That means if you left your job voluntarily, you usually won’t qualify for unemployment. A major exception is that you can still collect unemployment if you “good cause” to quit. What constitutes “good cause” depends on your state’s rules.
If you’ve quit your job and want to apply for unemployment benefits, there are a few things to remember:
- If you had “good cause” to leave your job, you’ll usually be entitled to unemployment benefits.
- States vary on how they define good cause, but most allow reasons such as unsafe working conditions, workplace harassment, or your own medical issues.
- If you quit, your employer might contest your claim to unemployment benefits. That means you’ll probably have to participate in a hearing and present evidence of your reasons for leaving in order to get benefits.
These points are all discussed in more detail below.
Read Also: Pa Unemployment Ticket Number Tracker
Common Appeals: Voluntary Quits And Misconduct
Unemployment Insurance offers benefits to workers whose employment ended through no fault of their own. There are three general terms used in the unemployment context to illustrate how your employment ceased via discharge, quitting, or a lay-off. It is important to know the differences between these terms because it will determine whether you meet the eligibility requirements to obtain benefits.