Saturday, May 18, 2024

How To Win Unemployment Overpayment Appeal

Don't Miss

What Happens At An Unemployment Insurance Hearing

What to Do If You Received Unemployment Overpayment Letter | NBC10 Philadelphia

I was denied my unemployment compensation, and I appealed. Now I have a hearing scheduled. Do I need to go to the hearing?

If you want a chance at getting unemployment benefits, you must attend the hearing. If you were denied benefits when you first applied for unemployment and then you dont show up at your hearing, the appeal will be dismissed and you will not be able to try to get these benefits.

What happens if the employer doesnt show up for the hearing?

If the employer is the one who appealed, and the employer does not show up, the Administrative Law Judge should dismiss the appeal. If you are the one that appealed, and the employer does not show up, the ALJ will go on with the hearing.

If you go to the hearing and the employer does not show up, you should win your case. This is especially true if you were fired from your job, because it is the employers responsibility to prove you were fired for just cause. If the employer isnt there, the employer cannot prove you were fired for just cause and you should win. If you quit your job, you have to prove you had good, work-related reasons for quitting. If your employer doesnt show up, you will probably still have to explain to the that you had good, work-related reasons for quitting.

Even if your employer does show up, you can still win. Both sides will present their sides of the case, and the ALJ will make a decision.

Do I need a lawyer for the hearing?

What happens at the hearing?

Last revised: 11-03

Claim Your Weekly Benefits During The Appeal

You should claim your weekly benefits while you are appealing the decision and for as long as you remain unemployed, even if the decision found you ineligible for any benefits. That way, if you win the appeal, you can receive retroactive benefits. For information about weekly benefit certification, see What Do I Have to Do to Keep Receiving Benefits?

Recommended Reading: Unemployment Holiday Delay 2020 Ny

Unemployment Insurance Law: The Claim And Appeal Process

The Texas Legislature established the Texas Employment Commission in 1936 in response to federal legislation mandating unemployment compensation systems in all 50 states. In 1996, the Legislature created a new agency, the Texas Workforce Commission , rolled TEC into the new agency, and added several new programs, but TWC has retained the responsibility for the state unemployment compensation program. The agency is headed by a board consisting of three members appointed by the Governor to staggered six-year terms. One board member represents labor, another represents employers, and the third member represents the public at large. Although TWC administers several employment law statutes, the majority of the agency’s resources are devoted to carrying out the Texas Unemployment Compensation Act .

Once an appeal has been filed, the Appeals Department will either dismiss the appeal, issue an on-the-record decision, or set up an appeal hearing. It will dismiss the appeal if it is filed outside the 14-day appeal period. It will issue an on-the-record decision affirming the late protest ruling if the employer fails to disagree with the fact that it filed a late protest to the initial claim notice. In all other cases, the Appeals Department will mail notices of the appeal hearing to the claimant, the employer, and any representatives they may have designated.

Read Also: Www Njuifile Net Schedule

At The Hearing What Arguments Can I Make About The Notice Of Overpayment

Most claimants who have been assessed an overpayment can make three types of arguments to either remove the overpayment entirely or lower the amount they will owe to the EDD:

  • Argue that you were eligible for benefits, so there was no overpayment. Often times, the EDD will incorrectly decide that you were not eligible for benefits. For example, the EDD may decide that you quit your job without a good reason, even though the reason you quit was the type of reason that allows you to access UI benefits. If you were eligible for UI, then you should not have been assessed an overpayment.
  • Argue that you did not make a willful false statement. If you were assessed a false statement penalty, you should argue that you did not make a willful false statement. It is important to get false statement penalties reversed for a few reasons. First, getting this decision reversed will mean you do not have to pay a false statement penalty. Second, if you dont get this decision reversed, you may have to serve penalty weeks in the future where you will not be able to receive UI benefits. Finally, you have to show that you did not make a willful false statement to be eligible to have the overpayment waived, or forgiven.
  • The overpayment is not your fault if you did not know, and could not reasonably know, that you were not eligible for benefits, or if you received benefits because of an error made by the EDD, and relied on the EDDs decision in good faith.

    Has The Dua Asked You To Return Money They Paid You

    Unemployment Appeal Letter Template Download Printable PDF ...


    Because of the Covid-19 emergency, many people are out of work and looking for unemployment insurance benefits. Many of the rules have changed because of this emergency. You may be able to get Unemployment faster and more easily than before. See Covid-19 and Unemployment Insurance.

    The Massachusetts Department of Unemployment Assistance is the agency that sends checks to people who claim unemployment benefits.

    If the DUA says that you were overpaid, you can challenge DUA’s decision, or the amount of the overpayment. Even if you agree that you were overpaid, you may not have to pay it back if you meet certain conditions.

    Don’t Miss: Apply For Unemployment Ms

    What Happens If My Waiver Request Is Denied

    If your waiver request is denied, you have the right to appeal. Appealing the decision means you are asking for a hearing and you can present evidence at the hearing. The DUA must receive your appeal within:

    • 10 days of the date on the denial notice, or
    • 30 days if you have good cause, or
    • 60 days or more if you fail to ask for a hearing earlier is because DUA did not give you with information in your primary language.

    If you lose at the hearing, you can ask the Board of Review to review your case. If the Board does not agree to review or reverse the waiver denial, you can appeal to District Court. Finally, you can write to the Director of the DUA, Department of Unemployment Assistance, 19 Staniford Street, Boston, MA 02114 within one year of the original decision and ask him to “redetermine the decision under Section 71 of the law”. There are strict time limits for all of these appeals. Ask a legal services office for information on these appeal deadlines.

    What To Do If You Receive An Overpayment Notice

    But what about people who are just caught in the middle of an antiquated system that is ill-equipped to handle requests from the newly unemployed? Lets posit that youve received a notice from your state unemployment office claiming that youve been overpaid by thousands of dollars. There was no red flag. You followed all the steps required in your initial filing, have been diligently certifying your claim weekly, and have been receiving the assistance that you thought was due to you. Now youve been told that you owe someor allof that back. What can you do?

    • File an appeal:If you feel that you received the notice in error, go to your state unemployment website to request a hearing.
    • Request a waiver:If the overpayment is legitimate, then you may be entitled to either a waiver or forgiveness of it. Either way, you may only have a small window of time to request such an action, so be sure to check with your states requirements.
    • Repay the money:Either contact your state department of labor to work out a repayment plan or simply pay the amount back in full.

    Recommended Reading: Njuifile Net Direct Deposit

    Learn About Indiana Unemployment Denial Appeals

    If an unemployment beneficiarys claim for benefits is denied or reduced and the beneficiary disagrees with that decision, he or she has the right to an appeal. The Indiana unemployment denial appeal will be heard by an Administrative Law Judge . After an applicant has filed their unemployment claim, he or she will receive a Determination of Eligibility through the mail. This notice will state whether or not he or she qualifies for benefits and explains how and why the decision was made.

    Applicants who cannot attend an unemployment denial appeal hearing may request a postponement no later than three days before the scheduled hearing. The ALJ will then review all evidence and issue a decision on the appeal within two weeks after the hearing. The unemployment applicants should bring any evidence related to their former employer which can assist their appeal.

    Unemployment claimants also have the option to appeal the ALJs decision to the UI Review Board within 18 days of the mailing date of the ALJ decision. Once the Review Board has rendered a decision on the case, the claimants next opportunity for appeal is to appeal to the Indiana Court of Appeals.

    What Caused The Overpayment

    Claimants having trouble appealing overpayment notices from DETR

    When an overpayment is created, a determination is sent that provides information on what caused the overpayment and lists the week you were overpaid. Check your mail or log on to and read all determination letter in your electronic mailbox. You can also find some common causes for overpayments on the Overpayment page.

    Don’t Miss: 18883137284

    How Do I Write An Appeal Letter

    You have to state your reason and convince that you have a right to not repay the overpayment. Below is an example to make an unemployment overpayment appeal letter:

    Dear Mr. Louis

    The Labor Department sent me a notice on December 20, 2020, which states that my former employer file an appeal for my unemployment benefits. Its stated that I have to pay back the payment. I have attached some required documents to appeal the decision. I object to that appeal, and I have used all my money to pay all of my living expenses. I am still looking for a job and having no saving to repay the money.

    On July 12, 2020, my former employer fired me and replace my job position with his son. At that time, I applied for an unemployment benefit which has been accepted by the Labor Department. I have witnesses who are willing to testify that my former employer fired me just to get his son into my former position. For this reason, I ask for a formal hearing and look ahead to your decision.


    Alexandria Hammington

    Thats all our brief description of an unemployment overpayment appeal letter and its sample. Hope it can help you to get a new idea.

    Our Unemployment Appeal Hearing Tips

    Given the current unemployment rate in Minnesota, more and more unemployed individuals are seeking benefits from the states unemployment insurance system. At the same time, economic pressure has compelled employers to appeal former employees applications for unemployment benefits at an ever-higher rate. The result, at least based on anecdotal observations among employment lawyers, has been an uptick in the number of contested telephone unemployment appeal hearings. Most often, these hearings revolve around one of two issues: 1) whether the employee was terminated for employment misconduct or 2) whether the employee quit for a good reason caused by the employer.

    After representing numerous employees and employers in this process over the past several years, I have reached the point where I can make a number of observations about what works and what doesnt work in these unusual proceedings. The following list of DOs and DONTs represents a summary of these observations and can increase your chances of winning your unemployment appeal hearing.

    4. Dont send the judge a long written narrative of your case before the hearing. Such a narrative can and will be used by the other side to impeach you and your witnesses. You should instead rely upon the live testimony of your witnesses, the information contained in your exhibits, and your closing summation.

    Recommended Reading: Direct Deposit

    How To Make An Unemployment Overpayment Appeal Letter

    You are required to complete forms sent to you with the overpayment decision & attach them to the appeal letter. If you want to write such a letter, here are the steps you should follow:

    • In the first section, you will have to state all the reasons you think you shouldnt have to or are unable to repay overpayments.
    • After that, you will need to list the date of every decision you have got and each amount of overpayment.
    • Then, you should immediately complete the form that contains the details of your personal financial situation.
    • Next, you must return it within the designated timeframe.
    • In addition, it is also important to request a hearing so that labor department officials shall notify you as to whether a hearing will be granted or not.

    What Are Good Causes For Misconduct

    How To Win Unemployment Appeal In Ohio / Ohioans Urged To ...

    Although it is your employers responsibility to prove your misconduct and you technically dont have to prove anything, the right information can help refute your employers claims.

    The idea is to have justified reason for any accusation of willful misconduct that your employer might bring against you. Also, employees who engage in self-defense at the workplace may still be entitled to unemployment compensation benefits. Below reasons are listed that can justify an employees misconduct. If any apply to your situation, be sure to note the item so you can gather information to support your claim.

    If an employer cites your misconduct as violations of company rules or tardiness, the following lists are considered good causes for an employees misconduct.

    Don’t Miss: Va 100 Unemployable

    How To Win An Unemployment Appeal For Misconduct

    Weve talked about Unemployment Willful Misconduct around here before so today well look at some practical ways to be prepared for your unemployment appeal. There are both simple steps that you can take individually as well as a few critical steps that will further your case.

    Lets start with definitions.

    Unemployment Compensation an amount based on your past salary and your reasons for unemployment. Benefits last for up to 26 weeks in Pennsylvania. Heres the process of qualifying for UC benefits.

    Willful Misconduct an accusation of the employee by the employer that suggests that the employee participated in behavior counter to the employers interests, violated company policy, or participated in another workplace infraction.

    What Is A Waiver And When Should I Consider Asking For A Waiver

    If you get a decision that asks you to repay unemployment benefits, you may be able to ask for a “waiver.” A waiver is different than an appeal. You can only ask for a waiver if you have lost all appeals or the time for appealing is over. A waiver forgives all or part of the benefits you are asked to repay. In other words, you might have to repay a smaller amount, or nothing at all.

    Recommended Reading: Apply For Unemployment Tn

    How Do I Get Dua To Stop Collecting The Overpayment While I Ask For A Waiver

    The only way to make sure DUA doesn’t collect the overpayment while you are asking for a waiver is to pay attention to all the notices you get. Respond to all the notices within the time frames the notices describe.


    In the notices DUA will call collecting the overpayment “recoupment”.

    You need to file the waiver request within 15 days of your notice of overpayment to stop the DUA from collecting the overpayment. If you file within that 15 days, DUA will not try to recover any of the overpayment unless they deny your waiver and the waiver denial becomes final. Even if they deny your waiver you can “appeal” the denial. There are several appeal processes you can go through to try to get a waiver of overpayment. The whole time you are appealing they cannot collect the overpayment from you. But it is very important to pay attention to the deadlines. See question /#10.

    Why Does The Notice Of Overpayment Say That I Have To Pay A Penalty To The Edd What Does This Penalty Mean

    Kansas City-area man wins unemployment overpayment appeal

    Under California law, the EDD can make a claimant pay a penalty if the claimant makes a willful false statement to the EDD in an effort to obtain benefits. This penalty can be up to an additional 30 percent of the amount the EDD believes was wrongfully paid to the claimant. The EDD also usually penalizes a claimant for an alleged false statement by making the claimant ineligible for benefits they would otherwise receive in the future. The claimant could not be able to receive benefits for between 5 and 15 weeks, either during the claimants current period of unemployment, if they are still unemployed, or years later when the claimant becomes unemployed again. These penalties are intended to punish claimants who are trying, through fraud, to get benefits they are not entitled to. But in practice, the EDD regularly imposes false statement penalties when a claimant accidentally made a mistake on one of the many complex forms sent by the EDDand sometimes even when the claimant was telling the truth!

    Recommended Reading: Ticket Number Unemployment

    What Is A Notice Of Overpayment And Why Did I Get It

    A Notice of Overpayment is a document that EDD sends to claimants when EDD believes the claimant received benefits incorrectly. The notice will tell you how much EDD thinks that you need to pay back.

    If you do not appeal the Notice of Overpayment and get the decision reversed, you will have to pay this money to the EDD. The EDD may attempt to collect the money you owe by taking money out of your paycheck or tax refund. If the EDD believes you made a willful false statement, you may be penalized by not being able to receive UI benefits in the future when you are otherwise eligible, for example the next time you become unemployed.

    Even if you agree with EDD that you received benefits incorrectly, you may still want to appeal if EDD is penalizing you for making a false statement, and you did not intentionally give EDD information that caused the overpayment. It is possible to get the false statement penalties reversed, even if the overpayment itself is correct and you need to pay back EDD for the overpayment amount.

    More articles

    Popular Articles