Pro: Quitting Avoids The Unpleasantness Of Losing Your Job Suddenly
One big advantage with quitting is that you control the story of leaving the job, rather than having it decided for you. Victorio Milian, a human resources consultant at Humareso, said that in his 15-plus years of experience, being terminated is more emotionally fraught for people than quitting.
Even when they have an adversarial relationship with the employer, even when they know, OK theres all this progressive discipline against me, theyve made it clear that any further missteps are going to result in a termination, when youre actually administering it to that person, it is still always an emotional gut punch for that person, he said. So for me, you can avoid that by taking the reins yourself and choosing the way youre going to exit the workplace.
Particularly if you are in a job you hate, quitting may also come with much-needed peace of mind that you are finally leaving behind unreasonable bosses and co-workers, and not just suffering until an uncertain end date.
Ultimately Its Up To You To Decide Whats Best
How you choose to leave a job should ideally be a decision you weigh carefully, no matter which course you instinctually prefer.
If given the choice between resigning and being fired, employees should pause and seriously consider the benefits of a termination that dont exist with a resignation, Stygar said, who recommends consulting with an employment attorney if you have questions around severance and unemployment benefits.
Definitely dont knee-jerk and resign just to save face. Think about what you are doing. Its a business decision, Stygar said.
Broadly speaking, Milian has a different perspective. He said that if you have a choice, he believes that leaving under your own willpower is best so that you get to define your career story. But he advised that No matter what the scenario is, be proactive, not reactive.
If you are weighing the options of either being terminated or quitting on your own, you have to do the research to weigh the pros and cons of each in the context of your situation, he said. And that will determine ideally the best course of action.
Is It Better To Quit Before You Get Fired From A Job
Many of us dont always get to choose how we leave a job. But when you do see the writing on the wall at your company, you have an opportunity to consider your options.
Maybe you see finances are in the red, hear grim updates at all-hands meetings, or otherwise know that a layoff may be imminent. Maybe youre just reaching a breaking point with your boss and are more than ready to work somewhere else.
This is the crossroads you face: Do you quit on your own terms, or wait to see if your employer lays you off or fires you?
Both options come with major consequences. How you leave a job, or how a termination happens to you, can have ripple effects for your professional reputation and future financial benefits.
Heres what you need to weigh when deciding whether to exit on your own or wait to be ushered out:
Also Check: Can You File Bankruptcy On Unemployment Overpayment
If You’re Fired For Refusing To Work Due To Coronavirus Concerns
Can you get unemployment benefits if you were fired for refusing to work because of concerns about exposure to the coronavirus ? It depends. You may have a legal right to refuse to work under conditions that a reasonable person would believe create a risk of serious harm, if there isn’t enough time to get an inspection from the federal Occupational Safety and Health Administration and you raised the problem with your employer. So if you brought up your concerns about undue exposure to COVID-19 at work, and your employer wasn’t instituting reasonable precautions to protect employees, you might be eligible for unemployment benefits after being fired for refusing to work under those conditions. In most states, however, you probably won’t be eligible for benefits if your employer offered the appropriate training and equipment to protect you from the virus, but you chose to stay home anyway. If you’re in doubt about whether your employer’s protective measures were sufficient, you can apply for unemployment and allow your state’s unemployment agency to make this determination.
Pro: If You Quit You Dont Have To Deal With The Reputational Risk That Comes With Getting Fired
Future employers are generally understanding when someone loses a job due to a layoff, particularly during the coronavirus pandemic. But getting fired for performance can be a blow to your reputation that you may have to explain to unsympathetic interviewers.
There is an inherent bias on the part of most hiring managers and recruiters when they come across a candidate that was fired from a previous role, Milian said. He noted that depending on the role and the state, future employers may find out about your firing during a reference check where they ask your past employer questions like, Was this an employee in good standing? Were there any disciplinary actions in the last 12 months?
Of course, getting fired doesnt always mean your employers have the opportunity to badmouth you. California-based labor and employment attorney Ryan Stygar said itmay be possible to negotiate a neutral reference check in severance agreements or in settlement agreements for wrongful termination claims, ensuring your employer cannot talk negatively about you.
Recommended Reading: Unemployment Change Address
Rules For Unemployment After Quitting
A good rule of thumb is to ask friends or family if they would have quit in the same situation. Leaving because you wanted more money isnt usually a good enough reason to quit if you are going to need unemployment benefits.
You can still get benefits if you can prove:
- A reasonable person would not have stayed at the job
- Sexual harassment or discrimination
- Reduction in hours or wages
- You are being threatened about being fired
- Your job is unsafe
- You are being harassed or abused because you are a whistleblower
Many attorneys offer a free phone consultation. You should explain the situation at work and ask them if you have a case. They can explain the likelihood of you winning your case and your various options for unemployment.
While it is advisable to consult with an attorney who can advise you on the potential pitfalls of unemployment applications, you may also file for unemployment benefits on your own. In your application, you may be afforded a chance to explain the situation. If you are denied, you do have the chance to appeal the denial and try again.
Some Reasons For Termination Might Make You Ineligible For Unemployment Benefits
By Lisa Guerin, J.D.
To collect unemployment benefits, you must be out of work through no fault of your own. Workers who are laid off for economic reasonsdue to a plant closing, a reduction-in-force , or because of lack of work, for exampleare eligible for unemployment benefits. But employees who are fired are not always eligible for unemployment, at least not right away. It depends on the reasons why the employee was fired.
Read Also: What Day Does Unemployment Get Deposited In Nc
Most Importantly Dont Lose Faith In Yourself
A firing can be demoralizing but remember it is only one employer’s decision. There will be other, more suitable options for you. Take the time to regroup and find a job that is a better fit for you and your interests. It may be that this wasnt the right job for you, and a push to find a new one is just what you needed.
Employers Have Financial Incentives To Fight Claims
Many employees wonder why their former employer is involved in their claim at all. After all, if you have already lost your job, why is your former boss trying to deny you your much-needed unemployment benefits? The reason is relatively simple: Massachusetts employers may be required to pay more in insurance taxes if their former workers obtain unemployment benefits.
Unfortunately, in some cases, this system leads some unscrupulous employers to behave badly, trying to protect the finances of the company to the detriment of former employees. Indeed, potentially, your initial unemployment benefits claim may be approved and it may be your employer that requests a hearing to try to appeal the decision. Regardless of how your case gets to a hearing, your ex-employer is likely to be represented by a legal professional during that part of the process. As such, it is critically important that you have an experienced Springfield employee rights lawyer by your side as well.
You May Like: Www Tn Gov Workforce Howtofileui
Rules For Unemployment After Being Fired
If you are fired for a serious issue at work, and you are the cause, then unemployment may be denied. Larger problems, called infractions, can include treating other employees poorly, not doing your job, stealing, or breaking the law.
If you are let go or laid off for a general or neutral reason, then unemployment should be pretty straight forward for you. These situations might include:
- Laying off employees because of a business reason
- Being fired for small issues like being late or making a mistake
You will also quality for unemployment if:
- Your manager or HR person is discriminating against you
- Your company is punishing you for being a whistleblower
You have certain protections and if your rights are violated, then you can file suit. You will need to prove these claims. Your attorney will walk you through the process and gather the evidence needed to fight for your benefits.
A Really Bad Workplace Could Also Make You Eligible
Every employees circumstances are at least somewhat unique and will come with their own wrinkles. Some state agencies, for instance, may be far more stringent in their denial of benefits. However there are some steps you can take to better your odds, even if your situation does not seem to make you the ideal unemployment candidate.
Employees who quit due to constructive dischargewhich means that the employer created conditions that made continued employment unbearablewill receive unemployment benefits, but proving constructive discharge isnt easy, HR executive and career coach Lynda Spiegel told us.
Even if you arent fired, you might still be able to receive benefits.
You can even get benefits without an involuntary termination if there is a significant reduction in work hours reducing your pay or you resign for good cause attributable to your employer , Wood suggested. You can usually file a claim for benefits without a lawyer, but should consider consulting one if your benefits are denied.
Also Check: Are Unemployment Benefits Delayed On Holidays 2020
When To Take Your Case To A Lawyer
With so many attorneys offering a free phone call consultation, it is a good idea to run your situation past a professional to get their initial opinion and information about the costs of pursuing a claim. If you hire counsel, they will be able to advise you on accepting the denial, doing an appeal, or taking things to court.
You can always seek a second legal opinion as well. If you feel your job loss and unemployment denial were wrong, then you should start gathering knowledge on what you can do about it.
If You Quit For Good Cause
You may be eligible for unemployment if you quit your job. In most cases, you must prove that the conditions were so bad that no reasonable person would stay.
Maybe you faced a dangerous work environment, harassment or discrimination. Perhaps your employer reduced your hours, demoted you into an unsuitable role or didnt pay you on time or in full. You might have good cause if you simply could no longer afford transportation to and from work.
If you quit your job, however, you must show that you did everything you could to improve the situation. Quitting was your last available recourse.
You may also qualify if you quit work due to a medical condition or to care for an ill family member. Some states may even provide benefits to people who quit due to domestic violence. In these situations, applicants dont need to prove that they tried everything they could to keep their job.
If youre considering quitting due to COVID-19-related issues, check with your states unemployment office about its benefit requirements. The Department of Labor lists each states contact information.
Read Also: How To Earn Money When Unemployed
Reasons For Ineligibility For Unemployment Insurance
You can quickly see why this wouldnt work for people who have quit their jobs. They could get hired one week and quit the next and then just sit on unemployment for 26 weeks until their check runs out and theyre required to get another job.
In most cases, quitting your job makes you ineligible for unemployment. There are few exceptions, like if you had good cause for quitting, you might still be able to get payments. Example scenarios include an unsafe work situation or a job where you were being harassed and can document that you reported it and they didnt do anything to help you.
Getting fired from your job can make you ineligible, too. If youre trying to get fired and doing all the wrong things, your employer has a right to fire you and youre ineligible for unemployment insurance. But if youre fired unjustly, you might be eligible.
Another eligibility requirement for unemployment is based on your states threshold for earned wages or time worked. This is called the base period.
In almost every state the base period is a year, which means youll have to have worked for a year, before losing your job, to collect unemployment benefits. Some states require you to have worked a certain amount of hours in the base period before qualifying. Its best to check with your state unemployment office to see if you will qualify.
Can Fired Employees Collect Unemployment
Not all fired employees are eligible to collect unemployment. Heres what you need to know if you’re letting someone go.
Eligibility for unemployment is dependent on the situation under which the person was let go.
When an employee is fired, they may wonder if they are allowed to collect unemployment benefits. This can be a tricky gray area, because eligibility often depends on why the employee was terminated.
In general, unemployment benefits are available to those who were let go through no fault of their own. However, if someone was fired due to misconduct or violation of company policy, they might be ineligible to collect unemployment.
Below, we outline how unemployment works, the factors that impact eligibility for benefits and the rights of fired employees.
Recommended Reading: Are Unemployment Benefits Delayed On Holidays 2020
Q: How Do You Apply For Unemployment Compensation
A: Applications for unemployment compensation may be submitted by phone with the UC Service Center at 1-888-313-7284, Monday, Tuesday, Thursday, and Friday, 8:00 am to 4:00 pm. Only persons with Social Security Numbers ending in an odd number may call on Mondays. Only persons with SSNs ending in an even number may call on Tuesdays. All claimants may call on Thursdays and Fridays. Videophone service for ASL users is available only on Wednesdays from 12:00 noon to 4:00 pm. Applications may also be submitted anytime online at;www.paclaims.state.pa.us/UCEN/Login.asp. You should apply for unemployment compensation benefits as soon as you possibly can after losing or leaving your job. The UC Service Center will interview you and your former employer to determine if you should receive unemployment compensation. You will receive a written notice telling you whether or not you will receive unemployment benefits.
Attempts To Change State Laws Have Largely Stalled
Legislators in several states have proposed making discrimination based on vaccine status illegal and guarantee access to unemployment benefits if a worker doesnt comply with their employers vaccination policy.
Tennessee saw one such bill introduced in its Senate in to prevent discrimination based on vaccination status. The bill would also ensure access to unemployment benefits for unvaccinated people who decide to leave their jobs, but it has not yet been considered in committee.
In Idaho, a bill passed the House to prohibit discrimination based on vaccination status. It has not been taken up in the Senate, where it has sat since February.
A bill in Michigans House of Representatives would prohibit employers from discriminating against employees who dont get vaccinated. It was introduced in March, but not considered in committee.
In January 2021, Alaskas General Assembly introduced a bill to prohibit mandatory vaccination in the workplace. Arizona, sought to would prohibit vaccination status as a condition of employment, but the proposal; died in committee in .
Smith says its unlikely that any laws like this get passed to protect workers who dont want to get vaccinated.
If in fact those types of laws are passed, it is completely opposite of the basic fundamentals of labor and employment law, that if youre fired for cause, you cant get unemployment, she says.
Don’t Miss: What Ticket Number Is Pa Unemployment On
I Was Denied Unemployment Benefits What Now
If you went through the process of filing a claim and conducting and interview and you received a notice denying you unemployment benefits, there is still another option for you. You are allowed to file an appeal within 30 days of the mailing date of your notice. You must mail in your appeal claim to the address on your notice. It must include:
- Your name
The Office of Appeals will notify you at least 10 days in advance of the time and place of your hearing. At the hearing an Administrative Law Judge will give both sides a chance to present their evidence and will issue a written decision. If you are looking for help with any of these steps of the process to receive unemployment benefits, one of our experienced unemployment attorneys will be happy to assist you.
Unemployment Lawyer in Los Angeles
